All right Beer We Go Family! I am over the disaster that was last season. Here is our thoughts on the NFL Draft.
Pittsburgh Steelers 2025 NFL Draft: Building Blocks for the Future
The Pittsburgh Steelers entered the 2025 NFL Draft with clear needs and a vision for solidifying their roster. After a disastrous end of the season and a fast Wild Card exit 2024, the focus was on adding physicality and depth, particularly on the defensive side of the ball, while also addressing key offensive positions. General Manager Omar Khan and Coach Mike Tomlin appear to have executed a draft that aligns with the team’s identity and aims for both immediate impact and long-term development.
One of the biggest stories of the draft was who WASN’T drafted. Despite several chances to get him and a glaring opening at Quarterback, the Steelers passed on Shedeur Sanders. According to ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler, the Steelers organization “did not reach a consensus on Sanders as a slam dunk pick.” While some in the organization may have been interested, there wasn’t a strong enough agreement to spend an earlier draft pick on him and avoid bringing in the sure media circus.
Instead, the Steelers followed their usual plan of attack and picked up players who fit the “Steelers Mode”.
Here’s the BWG take on the Steelers’ selections in the 2025 NFL Draft:
Round 1, Pick 21: Derrick Harmon, DT, Oregon
The Steelers kicked off their draft by bolstering their defensive line with the selection of Derrick Harmon from Oregon. This pick addresses a significant need, especially with Cameron Heyward entering his age-36 season.
- Analysis: Harmon is a disruptive interior pass rusher who fits the Steelers’ physical and aggressive defensive mold. He earned a high pass-rush grade in 2024 and is seen as a potential successor to Heyward. His ability to contribute immediately while learning from a veteran like Heyward is a significant plus.
- What he brings: Size (6’4″, 320 lbs), strength, and a knack for collapsing the pocket. He excels against true pass sets and can also contribute against the run.
Round 3, Pick 83: Kaleb Johnson, RB, Iowa
With Najee Harris departing in free agency, the Steelers looked to the running back position in the third round, selecting Kaleb Johnson from Iowa.
- Analysis: Johnson is a physical, early-down runner who provides a different dimension to the Steelers’ backfield compared to the shiftier Jaylen Warren and Kenneth Gainwell. He had impressive rushing numbers in 2024, showcasing his ability to gain yards after contact.
- What he brings: Size (6’1″, 224 lbs), power, and a downhill running style. He’s a bruiser who can wear down defenses and provides a strong complement to the existing running backs.
Round 4, Pick 123: Jack Sawyer, EDGE, Ohio State
Continuing to invest in their defense, the Steelers added edge rusher Jack Sawyer from Ohio State in the fourth round.
- Analysis: Adding Sawyer to a pass-rushing unit that already includes T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith provides valuable depth and potential for the future. Sawyer’s impressive pressure numbers in college highlight his ability to get after the quarterback.
- What he brings: Versatility, playmaking ability against both the run and pass, and a good frame (6’5″, 265 lbs). He has the potential to learn and develop behind established veterans.
Round 5, Pick 164: Yahya Black, DT, Iowa
The Steelers doubled down on the defensive line by selecting another Iowa Hawkeye, defensive tackle Yahya Black, in the fifth round.
- Analysis: Black provides further depth to the interior defensive line. While not primarily a pass rusher, he is known for his stoutness against the run and his ability to eat up double teams.
- What he brings: Run-stopping ability and the potential to develop as a rotational player on the defensive line.
Round 6, Pick 185: Will Howard, QB, Ohio State
Addressing the quarterback room, the Steelers selected Will Howard from Ohio State in the sixth round. With the uncertainty surrounding a potential Aaron Rodgers signing and the departure of other quarterbacks, adding a developmental prospect was a logical move.
- Analysis: Howard brings a combination of athleticism and a strong physique. He has experience as a multi-year starter in college and showcased his ability to perform in big games, leading Ohio State to a national title.
- What he brings: Size (6’4″, 236 lbs), athleticism, and experience. He’s a developmental quarterback who could potentially compete for a role down the line.
Round 7, Pick 226: Carson Bruener, LB, Washington
In the seventh round, the Steelers added linebacker Carson Bruener from Washington. He is the son of Steelers royalty Mark Bruener.
- Analysis: Bruener provides depth at the linebacker position and has experience as a productive college player, leading his team in tackles and interceptions in 2024.
- What he brings: Tackling ability and potential special teams contributions.
Round 7, Pick 229: Donte Kent, CB, Central Michigan
With their final pick, the Steelers selected cornerback Donte Kent from Central Michigan.
- Analysis: Kent adds depth to the cornerback room. As a team captain in college, he brings leadership qualities and experience as a starter.
- What he brings: Starting experience and potential depth in the secondary.
Overall Draft Analysis
The Pittsburgh Steelers’ 2025 draft appears to have focused on addressing key needs with an emphasis on physicality and defensive strength.
- Defense First: The selection of Derrick Harmon in the first round highlights the continued commitment to a strong defensive line. Adding Jack Sawyer and Yahya Black further reinforces this unit, providing both immediate depth and potential future starters.
- Running Back Reinforcement: Kaleb Johnson brings a power running element to the backfield, which could be crucial in complementing the skills of Warren and Gainwell.
- Quarterback Development: The addition of Will Howard provides a developmental quarterback prospect who could be groomed for the future.
- Depth and Special Teams: The late-round additions of Carson Bruener and Donte Kent offer potential depth at linebacker and cornerback, as well as possible contributions on special teams.
It wasn’t sexy and we didn’t get the franchise Quarterback, but the Steelers’ 2025 NFL Draft seems to have effectively addressed many needs on both sides of the ball. By prioritizing the defensive line early and adding a physical running back, they have reinforced their traditional strengths.
The selection of a developmental quarterback in the later rounds also shows an eye towards the future. Overall, this draft appears to have provided the Steelers with a solid foundation to build upon as they aim for a deeper playoff run.
The Undrafted Free Agents:
The Pittsburgh Steelers have historically found valuable contributors through the undrafted free agent (UDFA) market, and their 2025 class features several intriguing prospects who will be competing for a roster spot or a place on the practice squad. Here’s a detailed analysis of the Steelers’ 2025 UDFA signings:
- Sebastian Castro, Safety, Iowa
- Analysis: Castro is a smart and versatile defensive back who played extensively for a strong Iowa defense. While his athletic testing numbers might have led to him going undrafted, his football IQ, coverage ability (especially in zone), and run support are highly regarded. He was a two-time All-Big Ten honoree.
- Potential Impact: Castro’s versatility to play in the slot, in the box, or as a deep safety gives him a real shot at competing for a roster spot, especially given the need for depth in the Steelers’ secondary. His intelligence and experience in a well-coached program could make him a quick study in the NFL. Some analysts believe he has the best chance among the UDFAs to make the 53-man roster.
- J.J. Galbreath, Tight End, South Dakota
- Analysis: Galbreath was a productive pass-catcher at the FCS level, earning All-American honors. He’s considered an athletic move tight end with good receiving skills, hauling in a significant number of receptions and touchdowns in his college career.
- Potential Impact: With Arthur Smith now the offensive coordinator, tight end play could be emphasized. While Galbreath might be slightly undersized for a traditional in-line role, his athleticism and receiving ability could make him a valuable developmental player and a potential receiving threat from the position. He’ll need to prove his blocking ability to stick on the active roster.
- Ben Sauls, Kicker, Pittsburgh
- Analysis: Sauls is a local product who had a successful career at the University of Pittsburgh, kicking in the same stadium as the Steelers. He was consistent and had a strong leg, earning All-American recognition.
- Potential Impact: While Chris Boswell is the established kicker for the Steelers, bringing in Sauls provides competition and a potential long-term option. Sauls’ familiarity with Acrisure Stadium is a definite plus. He could potentially follow a path similar to other kickers who have developed behind Boswell and found NFL jobs elsewhere.
- Roc Taylor, Wide Receiver, Memphis
- Analysis: Taylor is a big-bodied receiver who was productive in his final two seasons at Memphis, showcasing his ability to make plays downfield. He averaged a healthy yards-per-reception in his senior year.
- Potential Impact: The Steelers have revamped their receiving corps, and Taylor’s size and potential as a downfield threat could make him an intriguing prospect. He’ll need to stand out in a crowded receiver room and potentially contribute on special teams to make the roster. His familiarity with former Memphis teammate Calvin Austin III could be beneficial.
- DJ Thomas-Jones, Fullback, South Alabama
- Analysis: Thomas-Jones is a versatile player who played tight end at South Alabama but is expected to transition to fullback for the Steelers. He has good receiving skills for his position, with a knack for finding the end zone.
- Potential Impact: The Steelers have shown a willingness to utilize a fullback, and Thomas-Jones’ receiving ability gives him a different dimension at the position. If he can effectively make the transition and contribute on special teams, he has a decent shot at making the roster, especially considering the Steelers reportedly gave him the largest guarantee among their non-quarterback UDFAs.
- Aiden Williams, Offensive Guard, Minnesota-Duluth
- Analysis: Williams comes from a smaller school but was a multi-year starter and an All-Conference selection. He’s considered a strong athlete, posting an impressive Relative Athletic Score.
- Potential Impact: Offensive line depth is always crucial, and Williams’ athleticism makes him an intriguing developmental prospect. Coming from a smaller program means he’ll face a significant jump in competition, but his athletic traits give him a chance to impress the coaching staff and potentially earn a practice squad role with the upside to develop further.
- Ke’Shawn Williams, Wide Receiver, Indiana
- Analysis: Williams is a smaller, shiftier receiver who has accumulated a significant amount of all-purpose yards in his college career, including a productive season at Indiana in 2024.
- Potential Impact: While undersized, Williams is known for his toughness and route-running ability. He’ll be competing for a slot receiver role and will need to showcase his quickness and ability to make plays in tight spaces. Special teams contributions could be key to his chances of sticking around.
Overall Analysis of the Steelers’ UDFA Class:
This UDFA class appears to be a solid group with potential in various positions. Several players possess traits that could translate to the NFL level, even if they weren’t drafted. The emphasis seems to be on finding players with specific skills or high football IQ who can compete for roles and provide valuable depth.
- High Potential for Roster Spots: Sebastian Castro and DJ Thomas-Jones seem to have the clearest paths to potentially making the 53-man roster due to team needs and their respective skill sets.
- Developmental Prospects: J.J. Galbreath and Aiden Williams are intriguing athletes who could develop into contributors with more coaching and experience.
- Special Teams Value: Ben Sauls has a clear path to potentially sticking around if he performs well in camp, while other UDFAs will need to show special teams prowess to enhance their chances.
- Competitive Position Battles: The wide receiver group is crowded, meaning Roc Taylor and Ke’Shawn Williams will need to quickly demonstrate their unique abilities to stand out.
The Steelers’ rookie minicamp and training camp will be crucial for these undrafted free agents to showcase their talent and make a case for a spot on the team. The Steelers have a history of finding gems in this group, and it will be interesting to see if any of these players can become the next UDFA success story in Pittsburgh.